U.N. Climate Change Expert Cites More Errors in Report
U.N. Climate Change Expert Cites More Errors in Report
Jeremy Page, South Asia Correspondent The Times
The Indian head of the U.N. climate change panel defended his position Friday even as further errors were identified in the panel’s assessment of Himalayan glaciers.
Dr. Rajendra Pachauri dismissed calls for him to resign over the Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change’s retraction of a prediction that Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035.
But he admitted that there may have been other errors in the same section of the report, and said that he was considering whether to take action against those responsible.
“I know a lot of climate sceptics are after my blood, but I’m in no mood to oblige them,” he told The Times of London in an interview. “It was a collective failure by a number of people,” he said. “I need to consider what action to take, but that will take several weeks. It’s best to think with a cool head, rather than shoot from the hip.”
The IPCC’s 2007 report, which won it the Nobel Peace Prize, said that the probability of Himalayan glaciers “disappearing by the year 2035 and perhaps sooner is very high.”
But it emerged last week that the forecast was based not on a consensus among climate change experts, but on a media interview with a single Indian glaciologist in 1999.
The IPCC admitted on Thursday that the prediction was “poorly substantiated” in the latest of a series of blows to the panel’s credibility.
Pachauri said that the IPCC’s report was the responsibility of the panel’s co-chairs at the time, both of whom have since moved on.
They were Dr. Martin Parry, a British scientist now at Imperial College London, and Dr. Osvaldo Canziani, an Argentine meteorologist. Neither was immediately available for comment.
“I don’t want to blame them, but typically the working group reports are managed by the Co-Chairs,” Pachauri said. “Of course the Chair is there to facilitate things, but we have substantial amounts of delegation.”
He declined to blame the 25 authors and editors of the erroneous part of the report, who included a Filipino, a Mongolian, a Malaysian, an Indonesian, an Iranian, an Australian and two Vietnamese.
The “co-ordinating lead authors” were Rex Victor Cruz of the Philippines, Hideo Harasawa of Japan, Murari Lal of India and Wu Shaohong of China.
But Syed Hasnain, the Indian glaciologist erroneously quoted as making the 2035 prediction, said that responsibility had to lie with them. “It is the lead authors — blame goes to them,” he told The Times. “There are many mistakes in it. It is a very poorly made report.”
He and other leading glaciologists pointed out at least five glaring errors in the relevant section.
It says the total area of Himalyan glaciers “will likely shrink from the present 500,000 to 100,000 square kilometers by the year 2035.” There are only 33,000 square kilometers of glaciers in the Himalayas.
Professor Hasnain, who was not involved in drafting the IPCC report, said that he noticed some of the mistakes when he first read the relevant section in 2008.
That was also the year he joined The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) in Delhi, which is headed by Dr Pachauri.
He said he realised that the 2035 prediction was based on an interview he gave to the New Scientist magazine in 1999, although he blamed the journalist for assigning the actual date.
He said that he did not tell Dr Pachauri because he was not working for the IPCC and was busy with his own programmes at the time.
“I was keeping quiet as I was working here,” he said. “My job is not to point out mistakes. And you know the might of the IPCC. What about all the other glaciologists around the world who did not speak out?”
Pachauri also said he did not learn about the mistakes until they were reported in the media about 10 days ago, at which time he contacted other IPCC members. He denied keeping quiet about the errors to avoid disrupting the UN summit on climate change in Copenhagen, or discouraging funding for TERI’s own glacier program.
Related Posts
-
Danish Police Beat Back Massed Climate Protesters [/caption] By JOHN M. BRODER and TOM ZELLER Jr. New York Times Published: December 16, 2009 COPENHAGEN — Police officers... -
Fla. man exonerated after 35 years behind bars [/caption] By MITCH STACY (AP) BARTOW, Fla. — James Bain used a cell phone for the first time Thursday, calling... -
Pirates seize second UK-flagged cargo ship [/caption] A UK-flagged cargo ship with 25 crew has been seized by pirates off the coast of Somalia. The Asian... -
Major UK airports reopen; Amsterdam stays shut [/caption] LONDON – London's two major international airports — Heathrow and Gatwick — reopened to some flights Monday after a... -
State of the climate: warming, with no sign of waning [/caption] Every year since 1990, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has released an annual report detailing the state of...
-
Glacier Scientist Admits to Fabricating Himalaya Scare Oooh... scary stuff, and so official-sounding, too. Can't you just hear the tree-huggers with their gritted teeth screaming that we... -
Lindsay Lohan In Twitter Fight With Joan Rivers, Dr. Drew Feud began when veteran comedian tweeted series of jokes riffing on embattled actress' legal troubles.By Gil Kaufman Linsday Lohan and... -
Climate Czar Ignores Climategate Obama Climate Czar Carol M. Browner, Committed Socialist WASHINGTON: On Wednesday Obama Climate Czar Carol Browner rejected Climategate evidence leaked... -
Beauty Holding: Investing in Models? Buying Shares of Models Gives Your Portfolio's "Asset Allocation" a Whole New Meaning Each week, 5-10 companies write me to... - A New Kyoto Treaty This year, leaders will broker a new agreement on climate change – a new Kyoto treaty. Negotiations are taking place...
